Finished The Body and need your next binge? The thriller mixes rebellion, prophetic visions, and religious dread in a town where fear spreads like wildfire. If you are hunting for supernatural shows like The Body, you are in luck. Finding compelling series like The Body that match that eerie mix of group hysteria and teenage paranoia is entirely possible.
From occult coming-of-age mysteries to isolated towns hiding dark secrets, these fifteen picks will hook you from the opening scene.
15 Supernatural Shows Like The Body: Similar Series You Can’t Miss
1. Yellowjackets (2021)
A wildly talented girls’ high school soccer team become the unlucky survivors of a plane crash deep in the Canadian wilderness. There is an immediate kinship here: both stories place a group of teenage girls at the center of an ordeal where everyday social rules vanish. While The Body leans into visions, Yellowjackets explores feral survival and fractured loyalties, making it one of the premier shows like The Body for fans who love intense ensemble drama.
IMDb: 7.7 | Where to watch: Paramount+
2. American Horror Story: Coven (2013)
A group of witches living together in a coven in New Orleans face dangerous enemies and struggle to ensure the survival of their community. If the occult aesthetic drew you into the story, this season takes that fascination several steps further. The two narratives boast distinct styles, but both dive into young women, supernatural forces, and shared panic, standing out as one of the best series like The Body for pure witchcraft thrills.
IMDb: 7.9 | Where to watch: Hulu
3. Wednesday (2022)
Wednesday Addams attempts to master her emerging psychic abilities, stop a killing spree and solve a supernatural mystery while attending Nevermore Academy. A student with unusual powers, an eerie school, and a tightening mystery check every familiar box. The tone leans more playful, yet underneath the gothic humor sits a gripping investigative pulse, earning it a top spot among lighter shows like The Body.
Also Watch: 15 Shows Like Wednesday
IMDb: 8.0 | Where to watch: Netflix
4. Midnight Mass (2021)
An isolated island community experiences miraculous events – and frightening omens – after the arrival of a charismatic, mysterious young priest. Reach for this title if the theological dread was what truly lingered in your mind. It transforms community faith into chilling horror, making it essential viewing for anyone tracking down haunting series like The Body that dissect faith and mass belief.
IMDb: 7.7 | Where to watch: Netflix
5. Chilling Adventures of Sabrina (2018)
As her 16th birthday approaches, Sabrina Spellman struggles to reconcile her identities as a half-witch and half-mortal while confronting supernatural threats to her family and the human world. Rebellion and dark rituals blend effortlessly here. The plot balances high school growing pains with sinister occult stakes, checking all the boxes for viewers seeking atmospheric shows like The Body filled with moody energy.
IMDb: 7.4 | Where to watch: Netflix
6. Evil (2019)
A skeptical psychologist joins a priest-in-training and a contractor to investigate unexplained events, alleged demonic possessions and other potentially supernatural occurrences. The lingering doubt makes this procedural click so well alongside the Catholic school mystery. The constant tug-of-war between psychological delusion and genuine demonic interference provides the exact cerebral chill you want from thoughtful series like The Body.
IMDb: 7.7 | Where to watch: Paramount+
7. Dare Me (2019)
A small-town cheerleading squad becomes entangled in a dangerous power struggle when a new coach arrives, disrupting relationships and exposing dark secrets. Stripping away the paranormal actually highlights the intense team politics at play. It trades prophetic omens for toxic loyalty and dangerous ambition, making it a standout pick among grounded shows like The Body focused on competitive female squads.
IMDb: 6.7 | Where to watch: Netflix
8. Cruel Summer (2021)
In a small Texas town, a popular teenager disappears, and another girl seemingly takes her place. Their intertwined stories reveal disturbing secrets and conflicting accounts of what happened. This mystery proves that psychological paranoia can rival any spectral curse. Its small-town setting and competing perspectives will captivate viewers seeking clever shows like The Body that hinge on community secrets.
IMDb: 7.4 | Where to watch: Hulu
9. The Society (2019)
A group of teenagers is mysteriously transported to a replica of their wealthy town, where they must establish their own society and figure out what happened to the adults. The unsettling realization that the world has broken down drives the narrative forward. Watching young adults navigate confusion and creeping dread mirrors the best parts of mystery-box series like The Body.
IMDb: 7.1 | Where to watch: Netflix
10. The OA (2016)
Having gone missing seven years ago, the previously blind Prairie returns home, now in her twenties with her sight restored. While many believe she is a miracle, others worry that she could be dangerous. Prairie’s return splits her hometown between reverent awe and acute suspicion, delivering a rich, mind-bending experience for anyone craving supernatural intrigue.
IMDb: 7.8 | Where to watch: Netflix
11. The Midnight Club (2022)
At a hospice for terminally ill young adults, eight patients meet every night to exchange frightening stories and make a pact that whoever dies first will send the others a sign from beyond. The late-night storytelling creates an intimate space where mortality and otherworldly signs collide, offering an emotional, spine-chilling ride that fits naturally on any horror watchlist.
IMDb: 6.5 | Where to watch: Netflix
12. School Spirits (2023)
Maddie, a teenager trapped in the afterlife, investigates her mysterious disappearance while adjusting to the supernatural world of high-school purgatory. A clever high-school setting and an unsolved murder turn this concept into an addictive, fast-paced watch that balances spectral lore with classic teen angst.
IMDb: 7.6 | Where to watch: Paramount+
13. The Beauty (2026)
Two FBI agents investigate a mysterious sexually transmitted virus that grants physical beauty but has terrifying and potentially deadly consequences. The story takes bodily changes and collective obsession in a fresh, unsettling direction. Watching society chase a miracle despite lethal warning signs creates genuine, stomach-turning tension from start to finish.
IMDb: 6.6 | Where to watch: Hulu
14. The Secret Circle (2011)
After a family tragedy, 16-year-old Cassie Blake moves to Chance Harbor, Washington, where she discovers that she is a witch and becomes involved in a secret circle of young witches. Cassie’s induction into an ancient coven blends high-school romance with generational curses, serving up a classic, spellbinding teen drama.
IMDb: 7.3 | Where to watch: The CW
15. Widow’s Bay (2026)
A skeptical mayor struggles to revive his isolated New England island community, where local superstitions and an ancient curse threaten to become terrifying realities. The slow slide from stubborn doubt to sheer terror makes this island nightmare a must-watch, nailing the pervasive dread of a town losing its mind.
Also Watch: 15 Shows Like Widow’s Bay
IMDb: 8.1 | Where to watch: Apple TV+
Also Watch: New OTT Releases This Week
Ready to feed your supernatural obsession? Pick your favorite, turn off the lights, and let the paranoia pull you in tonight.