If you’re searching for shows like Murder Mindfully, chances are you loved its unique mix of dark comedy, murder, clever storytelling, and morally questionable characters. The Netflix series manages to balance crime, suspense, and humor in a way that keeps viewers hooked from start to finish. Fortunately, there are plenty of other series that capture a similar vibe.
Whether you’re looking for quirky killers, accidental murderers, criminal masterminds, or darkly funny mysteries, these shows like Murder Mindfully should be at the top of your watchlist. From psychological thrillers to crime comedies, each of these series shares something special with Murder Mindfully.
15 Best Shows Like Murder Mindfully You Need to Watch Next
1. Sweetpea (2024)
If you enjoyed watching an underestimated character navigate a dangerous double life in Murder Mindfully, Sweetpea offers a similar thrill. The series follows a woman who has spent years being ignored and overlooked until she discovers that she might be capable of getting away with murder. Like Murder Mindfully, it blends dark humor with shocking acts of violence while exploring the psychology of an ordinary person pushed to the edge.
Based on the bestselling novel by C.J. Skuse, the series stars Ella Purnell in one of her darkest and most compelling performances. Its stylish direction and sharp writing make it one of the freshest dark comedy thrillers in recent years.
IMDb: 7.2 | Watch on: Starz
2. Fargo
Fargo is one of the finest crime anthologies ever made, featuring bizarre murders, eccentric criminals, and plenty of dark comedy. Much like Murder Mindfully, the show excels at turning seemingly normal situations into chaotic criminal disasters. Its clever storytelling, unexpected twists, and morally complex characters make it a perfect recommendation for fans of darkly comedic crime dramas.
Created by Noah Hawley and inspired by the Coen Brothers’ classic film, each season introduces a new cast and storyline. The show has earned multiple Emmy Awards thanks to its brilliant performances and unique storytelling style.
IMDb: 8.8 | Watch on: Prime Video
3. Dexter
If the morally conflicted criminal perspective in Murder Mindfully fascinated you, Dexter should be your next binge-watch. The series follows Dexter Morgan, a forensic analyst who secretly lives as a serial killer. Similar to Murder Mindfully, viewers spend much of the show rooting for someone who constantly breaks the law while trying to justify their actions.
Michael C. Hall’s iconic performance helped turn the show into a television phenomenon. The series ran for eight seasons and remains one of the most talked-about crime dramas ever produced.
IMDb: 8.6 | Watch on: Netflix
4. You
You take audiences deep inside the mind of a charming but dangerously obsessive protagonist. Like Murder Mindfully, the show combines dark humor, suspense, and a lead character who continuously rationalizes terrible decisions. The internal monologues and psychological storytelling make it especially appealing for fans who enjoyed the mental chess game of Murder Mindfully.
Based on Caroline Kepnes’ bestselling novels, the series stars Penn Badgley in a career-defining role. Its blend of romance, obsession, and murder keeps viewers hooked season after season.
IMDb: 7.6 | Watch on: Netflix
5. The Gentlemen
While it focuses more on organized crime than murder mysteries, The Gentlemen shares Murder Mindfully’s knack for blending criminal activity with sharp humor. The story follows an aristocrat who unexpectedly inherits a massive drug empire and becomes entangled in a world full of dangerous criminals, outrageous schemes, and constant surprises.
Created by Guy Ritchie, the series carries the same fast-paced energy and witty dialogue found in many of his films. The stylish visuals and colorful criminal characters make every episode wildly entertaining.
IMDb: 8.0 | Watch on: Netflix
6. Barry (2016)
Barry follows a professional hitman who dreams of leaving crime behind to become an actor. Like Murder Mindfully, it brilliantly balances laugh-out-loud comedy with serious violence and emotional drama. Both series explore characters struggling to reconcile their criminal actions with their desire for a better, more meaningful life.
Created by and starring Bill Hader, the show received widespread critical acclaim for its unique tone. It effortlessly switches between hilarious comedy and heartbreaking drama without ever losing momentum.
IMDb: 8.3 | Watch on: Prime Video
7. Mr Inbetween
This Australian gem centers on Ray Shoesmith, a criminal-for-hire trying to balance work, family, and relationships. Fans of Murder Mindfully will appreciate the show’s ability to make a dangerous criminal surprisingly relatable. Its blend of humor, violence, and everyday life creates a tone remarkably similar to what made Murder Mindfully so entertaining.
The series was created by and stars Scott Ryan, who originally introduced the character in his indie film The Magician. Its realistic dialogue and grounded storytelling have earned it a devoted fan following.
IMDb: 8.7 | Watch on: Prime Video
8. The Flight Attendant
A dead man, a missing memory, and a woman desperately trying to figure out what happened—The Flight Attendant delivers plenty of suspense. Similar to Murder Mindfully, it revolves around an ordinary person caught in extraordinary criminal circumstances. The mix of mystery, comedy, and psychological tension keeps viewers constantly guessing.
Kaley Cuoco leads the cast and also serves as an executive producer on the series. The show’s vibrant visual style and fast-paced storytelling help it stand out from traditional murder mysteries.
IMDb: 7.0 | Watch on: Prime Video
9. A Killer Paradox
This Korean thriller follows an average man whose accidental killing triggers a dangerous chain of events. Much like Murder Mindfully, it examines how ordinary individuals respond when they cross moral and legal boundaries. The cat-and-mouse chase between the protagonist and investigators creates constant tension throughout the series.
Based on a popular webtoon, the show combines crime, suspense, and dark humor in a way that feels fresh and unpredictable. Its unique premise quickly turns into an addictive thriller.
IMDb: 7.1 | Watch on: Netflix
10. The Woman in the House Across the Street from the Girl in the Window
With its intentionally absurd title and satirical take on murder mysteries, this series shares Murder Mindfully’s ability to mix comedy and crime. The story follows a grieving woman who believes she witnessed a murder, leading to increasingly bizarre events. Fans of quirky mysteries and dark humor will feel right at home.
Kristen Bell delivers a hilarious performance while cleverly poking fun at psychological thriller clichés. The series constantly keeps viewers guessing whether the mystery is real or imagined.
IMDb: 6.4 | Watch on: Netflix
11. Slow Horses
While more focused on espionage than murder, Slow Horses delivers the same sharp wit and morally gray characters that make shows like Murder Mindfully so addictive. The dysfunctional MI5 team at the center of the story constantly finds itself involved in dangerous situations, creating a compelling blend of suspense and dark comedy.
Based on Mick Herron’s bestselling spy novels, the series stars Gary Oldman in a critically acclaimed performance. Its clever writing and unconventional characters have made it one of the most celebrated spy shows of the decade.
IMDb: 8.3 | Watch on: Apple TV+
12. Kleo
Kleo follows a former East German spy and assassin who embarks on a revenge mission after being betrayed. Like Murder Mindfully, it features a charismatic lead character operating outside traditional moral boundaries. The combination of action, humor, and criminal intrigue makes it a standout choice among shows like Murder Mindfully.
The German series gained international attention for its stylish visuals and energetic storytelling. Jella Haase’s performance as Kleo adds both intensity and charm to the revenge-driven narrative.
IMDb: 8.4 | Watch on: Netflix
13. Obituary
This underrated dark comedy centers on a small-town obituary writer who turns to murder when work becomes scarce. If that premise sounds delightfully twisted, that’s because it shares many of the same qualities that make Murder Mindfully so enjoyable. Both series find humor in surprisingly dark situations while following unconventional protagonists.
Produced in Ireland, the series combines small-town charm with a wonderfully macabre sense of humor. Its unique concept helps it stand out among modern crime comedies.
IMDb: 7.0 | Watch on: Prime Video
14. We Got This
We Got This follows an American expat in Sweden who attempts to solve a famous murder case for the reward money. Similar to Murder Mindfully, the show thrives on awkward situations, flawed characters, and crime-driven storytelling. Its offbeat humor and mystery elements make it an entertaining hidden gem.
Created by and starring Schiaffino Musarra, the series mixes crime-solving with culture-clash comedy. The Scandinavian setting adds a fresh backdrop to its quirky investigation story.
IMDb: 6.9 | Watch on: Prime Video
15. Homicidios
For viewers who enjoyed the investigative aspects of Murder Mindfully, Homicidios offers a more traditional crime-solving experience. The series follows a team of detectives investigating murders connected to a single killer. While darker in tone, it delivers the same suspense and intrigue that fans of shows like Murder Mindfully often crave.
The Spanish crime drama focuses heavily on criminal profiling and psychological analysis. Its tense atmosphere and engaging mysteries make it a rewarding watch for crime-thriller fans.
IMDb: 7.1 | Watch on: Prime Video
Also Explore: 15 Shows Like A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder
If you’re looking for more shows like Murder Mindfully, these 15 series offer everything from dark comedy and psychological thrills to murder mysteries and morally complicated protagonists. So, which ones are you going to binge-watch first?