If Sterling Point left you wanting more stories filled with family mysteries, complicated relationships, emotional discoveries and beautiful small-town or summer settings, you’re in the right place. The show’s mix of hidden secrets, unexpected inheritance and coming-of-age drama gives it a distinctive charm. Some of these recommendations lean more heavily into mystery, while others focus on family, romance or finding a place to belong. Here are 15 shows like Sterling Point to add to your watchlist next.
15 Shows Like Sterling Point You Can’t Miss
1. We Were Liars
If the island mystery was your favorite part of Sterling Point, this should be your first pick. We Were Liars follows a wealthy family whose private island holds years of buried secrets, with every episode revealing another piece of its complicated past. Family tension, emotional relationships and an isolated summer setting give the series an atmosphere remarkably close to Sterling Point.
IMDb: 6.8/10 | Where to Watch: Prime Video
2. The Way Home
Family secrets, emotional reunions and unanswered questions about the past make The Way Home one of the strongest recommendations on this list. The story follows three generations of women as they reconnect and gradually discover truths about their family’s history. Its combination of mystery, belonging and complicated family relationships delivers much of the same emotional pull as Sterling Point.
IMDb: 8.1/10 | Where to Watch: Hallmark+ and Prime Video
3. The Hardy Boys
Frank and Joe Hardy return to their hometown and quickly become involved in a mystery connected to their own family. The sibling teamwork, hidden clues and steadily unfolding secrets make this one of the closest matches to Sterling Point. Viewers who enjoyed watching Annie and her brother uncover pieces of their family’s past should find plenty to like here.
IMDb: 7.0/10 | Where to Watch: Hulu
4. Northern Rescue
After a heartbreaking loss, a family leaves the city behind and begins a new life in a quiet lakeside town. The picturesque setting, family relationships and journey of rebuilding make Northern Rescue an especially natural follow-up to Sterling Point. Both stories show how moving somewhere unfamiliar can reveal new sides of a family and completely change its future.
IMDb: 6.9/10 | Where to Watch: Netflix
5. The Summer I Turned Pretty
Not every similar show needs a mystery. The Summer I Turned Pretty captures the warmth of unforgettable summers, changing relationships and the emotional highs and lows of growing up. Much like Sterling Point, it shows how one special place can shape a young person’s life while keeping family, friendship and romance at the heart of the story.
Also Read: Shows like The Summer I Turned Pretty
IMDb: 7.2/10 | Where to Watch: Prime Video
6. My Life with the Walter Boys
After losing her parents, Jackie moves in with a large family and suddenly finds herself surrounded by unfamiliar people, new routines and unexpected connections. Her struggle to adjust while figuring out where she belongs closely echoes the emotional side of Sterling Point. Both shows revolve around young characters rebuilding their lives while forming relationships that slowly begin to feel like home.
Also Read: Gripping Shows like My Life with the Water Boys
IMDb: 6.8/10 | Where to Watch: Netflix
7. Outer Banks
Adventure takes center stage in Outer Banks, where a group of teenagers follows clues connected to hidden treasure, dangerous secrets and complicated family histories. It is considerably faster-paced than Sterling Point, but the combination of mystery, friendship, romance and discoveries about the past creates a similar binge-worthy appeal.
IMDb: 7.5/10 | Where to Watch: Netflix
8. Locke & Key
Don’t let the fantasy elements fool you. At its heart, Locke & Key is about siblings moving into an inherited family home and gradually uncovering secrets left behind by previous generations. The mysterious property, family history and strong sibling dynamic give it considerably more in common with Sterling Point than you might initially expect.
IMDb: 7.3/10 | Where to Watch: Netflix
9. Sullivan’s Crossing
Life takes an unexpected turn for a successful doctor when she returns to her father’s campground after years away. Old relationships begin resurfacing as she reconnects with her family and starts reconsidering what she really wants from life. Its scenic setting, complicated family ties and focus on self-discovery make it an appealing choice for viewers who loved the emotional side of Sterling Point.
IMDb: 7.1/10 | Where to Watch: Netflix
10. Secrets of Sulphur Springs
This series blends mystery, friendship and family history in an entertaining way. After moving into an old hotel with his family, a young boy begins investigating strange events connected to the property’s past. Anyone who enjoyed watching old secrets slowly come to light in Sterling Point should find this an easy show to get into.
IMDb: 7.6/10 | Where to Watch: Prime Video
11. The O.C.
At first glance, The O.C. may seem quite different, but both stories revolve around young people entering unfamiliar worlds and trying to figure out where they belong. As Ryan adjusts to life with a new family, the series explores trust, romance, identity and complicated relationships. Those themes make it a strong choice for viewers more interested in the coming-of-age side of Sterling Point.
IMDb: 7.6/10 | Where to Watch: Prime Video
12. Anne with an E
Few shows capture the feeling of finding a place to call home as beautifully as Anne with an E. Through Anne’s experiences with belonging, friendship, family and personal growth, the series delivers the same kind of emotional warmth that helps make Sterling Point so easy to connect with. It lacks the central mystery but more than makes up for it with heart.
IMDb: 8.6/10 | Where to Watch: Netflix
13. Ginny & Georgia
Ginny & Georgia leans much more heavily into family drama, but complicated relationships, buried secrets and a young protagonist trying to understand herself still make it relevant here. The series balances coming-of-age struggles with revelations about the past, giving viewers plenty of emotional twists along the way.
IMDb: 7.5/10 | Where to Watch: Netflix
14. Finding Her Edge
Finding Her Edge is more grounded and less mysterious, but its coming-of-age story is filled with personal challenges, changing relationships and questions about identity and the future. Viewers who particularly enjoyed watching Annie navigate unfamiliar experiences and learn more about herself may connect with its emotional journey.
IMDb: 5.9/10 | Where to Watch: Netflix
15. Every Year After
This romantic drama follows two childhood friends whose lives remain connected over the years despite heartbreak, distance and changing circumstances. It focuses far more on romance than mystery, but shares Sterling Point‘s interest in how childhood memories, family experiences and important places can continue shaping people long after they grow up.
Also Read: 15 Shows Like Every Year After
IMDb: 6.3/10 | Where to Watch: Prime Video
If you’re looking for the closest experience to Sterling Point, start with We Were Liars, The Way Home, The Hardy Boys or Northern Rescue for their mix of family secrets, mystery and emotional relationships. For more coming-of-age romance and self-discovery, The Summer I Turned Pretty and My Life with the Walter Boys are especially strong choices.
Whether you’re after another mystery, a beautiful escape or simply a story about finding where you belong, these 15 shows like Sterling Point should keep your watchlist busy.