Sometimes, the best binge-watches are the ones you least expect. These are the shows we clicked on with zero expectations—maybe out of boredom, late-night curiosity, or just because they showed up in the “Trending Now” section.
But each one surprised us with gripping plots, unexpected twists, and performances that stuck with us long after the credits rolled. If you’re hunting for underrated Netflix suspense web series, this list is your goldmine.
1. Delhi Crime
We thought this would be just another police drama, but Delhi Crime stunned us with its raw intensity. Based on the 2012 Delhi gang rape case, this Emmy-winning show follows DCP Vartika (Shefali Shah) as she navigates the investigation, systemic failures, and public outrage. It’s hard-hitting and deeply humane.
2. Yeh Kaali Kaali Ankhein
With a kitschy name and retro vibes, we weren’t expecting much—but this dark love thriller totally delivered. A simple man finds himself trapped between a woman’s obsession and a political family’s power games. Suspense meets dark humor in this surprising gem.
3. She
Started as background noise, stayed for the character evolution. She follows a shy Mumbai constable who goes undercover and slowly finds her own power. With layered writing and emotional depth, this slow-burn thriller grows on you episode by episode.
4. The Railway Men
We hit play with no real expectations—and ended up crying. Based on the unsung heroes of the 1984 Bhopal gas tragedy, this one’s more than a suspense series. It’s a powerful tribute to bravery in the face of impossible odds.
5. Scoop
A crime drama about a journalist? Didn’t think it would be this addictive. Scoop dives into Mumbai’s media-politics-underworld triangle, where one woman is framed for a murder she didn’t commit. Riveting and sharply written.
6. Kohrra
We had no idea a murder mystery could feel this poetic. Set in rural Punjab, Kohrra unpacks grief, masculinity, and family secrets while investigating a wedding-week death. It’s slow, haunting, and incredibly gripping.
7. CAT
We hit play because of Randeep Hooda—and stayed for the gritty storytelling. CAT is a slow-boil thriller set in Punjab’s drug underworld, where betrayal runs deep and survival means playing dirty. It’s dark, intense, and worth every minute.
8. Aranyak
Honestly, we thought this would be a typical whodunit. But Aranyak surprised us with its eerie Himalayan setting and a plot steeped in local myths. Raveena Tandon impresses in a story that blends folklore and suspense with plenty of twists.
9. Kaala Paani
Clicked on it randomly—and we were hooked. Set during a mysterious outbreak in the Andaman Islands, Kaala Paani explores survival, secrets, and sacrifice. If you love dystopian thrillers with strong character arcs, don’t skip this one.
10. Killer Soup
This was a wild ride we never saw coming. Blending dark comedy, murder, and mistaken identities, Killer Soup is one of those shows that feels bizarre… until it hooks you completely. Manoj Bajpayee and Konkona Sen Sharma are unforgettable in this deliciously chaotic story.
These suspenseful Netflix series crept up on us with quiet brilliance and left a lasting impact. So if you’re looking for suspense thrillers that don’t rely on hype but pack a punch, start here-you might just find your next obsession.