Few stories capture the sting of adolescent alienation quite like Stephen King’s classic masterpiece. If you crave stories centered on tormented outcasts, telekinesis, and devastating revenge, tracking down great shows like Carrie is an absolute thrill. Fortunately, television delivers outstanding series like Carrie that channel that exact same mixture of social cruelty, toxic parenting, and terrifying, uncontainable power.
From bloody high school hallways to haunting family psychological dramas, these binge-worthy recommendations will deliver the dark thrills you want next.
15 Supernatural Horror Shows Like Carrie
1. I Am Not Okay With This (2020)
Sydney Novak navigates high school awkwardness and grief while discovering she possesses uncontrollable telekinetic abilities tied directly to her turbulent emotional distress. As her panic mounts, her private life spirals out of control. It stands as one of the best shows like Carrie, delivering an isolated outcast, cruel adolescent bullying, and a catastrophic school dance climax soaked in carnage.
IMDb: 7.5 | Where to watch: Netflix
2. Stranger Things (2016)
When a young boy vanishes in Hawkins, his friends uncover government conspiracies and alternate dimensions alongside a quiet girl named Eleven. Escaping abusive containment, Eleven uses her telekinetic gifts to survive cruelty. For viewers wanting shows like Carrie, this hit series mirrors the fear, social alienation, and formidable psychic fury unleashed when an exploited child fights back against cruelty.
Also Watch: 15 Shows Like Stranger Things
IMDb: 8.6 | Where to watch: Netflix
3. Bates Motel (2013)
Before turning into an infamous killer, young Norman Bates runs a roadside motel under the suffocating grip of his domineering mother, Norma. Their deeply toxic bond slowly shatters Norman’s sanity. Fans hunting for series like Carrie will appreciate how effectively this psychological thriller portrays an unstable teen broken by relentless maternal manipulation, guilt, isolation, and fatal domestic trauma.
IMDb: 8.1 | Where to watch: Prime Video
4. Yellowjackets (2021)
A high school soccer team survives a brutal plane crash in the northern wilderness, slowly turning toward savage factions and disturbing rituals to stay alive. The survivors remain haunted decades later. It works wonderfully for fans seeking shows like Carrie because it exposes raw teenage savagery, psychological deterioration, ostracization, and the horrific fallout when marginalized young women are pushed past their limits.
IMDb: 7.7 | Where to watch: Prime Video
5. Wednesday (2022)
Enrolled at Nevermore Academy, eccentric outcast Wednesday Addams juggles complex psychic visions while tracking down a monstrous serial killer terrorizing the local woods. While Wednesday proudly owns her dark quirks, viewers seeking series like Carrie will connect with her battle against suspicious townsfolk, rigid social hierarchies, and the hidden supernatural secrets lurking beneath an outwardly conventional high school.
Also Watch: 15 Shows Like Wednesday
IMDb: 8.0 | Where to watch: Netflix
6. The Haunting of Hill House (2018)
Decades after fleeing a notoriously haunted estate, the fractured Crain siblings must reunite to confront painful memories following a shocking family suicide. Their childhood trauma proves far more devastating than any specter. This gothic triumph is ideal for anyone who appreciated the profound emotional scars, suffocating domestic isolation, and destructive maternal dread at the dark heart of Stephen King’s tale.
IMDb: 8.5 | Where to watch: Prime Video
7. Midnight Mass (2021)
A dying coastal island experiences breathtaking miracles after a charismatic young priest arrives, sparking sudden devotion across the desperate community. However, horrific consequences soon follow this unnatural renewal. Fans drawn to series like Carrie will find the exploration of religious fanaticism, dogmatic guilt, pious hypocrisy, and catastrophic communal hysteria utterly gripping as blind faith turns completely lethal.
IMDb: 7.7 | Where to watch: Netflix
8. Chilling Adventures of Sabrina (2018-2020)
Half-witch teenager Sabrina Spellman wrestles with everyday high school life while standing against the wicked demands of the dark church. As demonic threats surround her friends, she must master terrifying magical abilities. It provides a thrilling watch alongside shows like Carrie, focusing on a gifted young woman rebelling against rigid dogmatic authority, ancient rituals, and suffocating ancestral expectations.
IMDb: 7.4 | Where to watch: Apple TV
9. It: Welcome to Derry (2025)
Set in the 1960s, this grim prequel unearths the horrifying origins of Pennywise terrorizing Derry’s vulnerable, neglected children. As community evils fester unchecked, youthful victims confront supernatural horrors. It is an essential pick among series like Carrie, blending classic King atmosphere, vicious small-town bullying, vulnerable misfits, and explosive horror emerging from the town’s darkest secrets.
IMDb: 7.9 | Where to watch: Apple TV
10. Chucky (2021-2024)
After bullied queer teen Jake Wheeler purchases an infamous vintage doll, deadly mayhem erupts across his suburban town as Charles Lee Ray claims fresh victims. Jake soon faces impossible moral choices. It mirrors the best beats of shows like Carrie, delivering visceral high school bullying, intense adolescent alienation, and a deeply cathartic, blood-drenched revenge fantasy against entitled classmates.
IMDb: 7.2 | Where to watch: Prime Video
11. Penny Dreadful (2014-2016)
In Victorian London, tormented clairvoyant Vanessa Ives battles insidious demonic forces alongside an assortment of classic literary figures. Despite facing horrifying monstrosities, Vanessa’s deepest battles remain internal. Audiences who loved the supernatural suffering of Carrie White will identify with Vanessa’s constant struggle against relentless spiritual isolation, societal rejection, and immense destructive abilities beyond her own mortal control.
IMDb: 8.2 | Where to watch: Prime Video
12. The Midwich Cuckoos (2022)
Following an eerie twilight blackout in a tranquil English commuter village, every fertile local woman wakes up inexplicably pregnant with telepathic children. These emotionless prodigies soon unsettle everyone. The story reflects the core dread in shows like Carrie, exploring community paranoia, the terror of strange adolescent minds, and the visceral fear of outcasts harboring perilous psychic powers.
IMDb: 6.7 | Where to watch: AMC+
13. The Beauty (2026)
A mysterious phenomenon grants a woman astounding physical allure, instantly altering how society treats her while extracting an unspeakable physical price. As public fixation turns predatory, her identity crumbles. The narrative evokes the tragic social vulnerability of Carrie, spotlighting how superficial popularity, societal judgment, and unexpected physical transformations can quickly unleash dangerous obsession and harrowing psychological fallout.
IMDb: 6.6 | Where to watch: Hulu
14. Widow’s Bay (2026)
Returning home after years away, a cautious woman investigates strange seaside happenings and finds her own family inextricably linked to the town’s buried history. The unsettling coastal fog conceals ancient nightmares. It echoes the quiet dread of King’s storytelling, mixing isolated community secrets, suffocating family baggage, and brooding supernatural mysteries that slowly bubble to the surface.
Also Watch: 15 Shows Like Widow’s Bay
IMDb: 8.1 | Where to watch: Apple TV
15. Dead Boy Detectives (2024)
Deceased teenage spirits Edwin and Charles team up with living psychic Crystal Palace to solve bizarre paranormal mysteries across the mortal realm. Even in death, the young detectives confront deep emotional trauma, forgotten grudges, and identity crises, offering a lighter yet heartfelt mystery adventure about outcast adolescents learning to harness extraordinary gifts on their own terms.
IMDb: 7.5 | Where to watch: Prime Video
Also Watch: New OTT Releases This Week
Grab your popcorn and dive into these delightfully chilling stories whenever you are ready for unforgettable supernatural dread and chaotic teenage vengeance!