Still obsessing over Fall River’s most infamous axe murders? You are not alone. There is something intoxicating about a historical scandal that leaves you debating guilt long after the credits roll. If you are craving more domestic dysfunction, morally ambiguous antiheroes, and messy courtrooms, here are 15 binge-worthy shows like Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story to cue up tonight.
15 Shows Like Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story
1. Alias Grace (2017)
Sarah Gadon turns in a spellbinding performance as Grace Marks, a 19th-century domestic servant convicted of murder alongside a stablehand. Through quiet prison therapy sessions, she spins a hypnotic web of half-truths, trauma, and repressed fury. Much like Lizzie, Grace remains an unsolvable puzzle. This is easily the most poetic, psychologically sharp match on our entire watch list.
IMDb: 7.6 | Where to watch: Netflix
2. The Staircase (2022)
Did novelist Michael Peterson bludgeon Kathleen with a blowpoke, or did she suffer a catastrophic fall? Colin Firth and Toni Collette shine in this dizzying, multi-perspective examination of a fractured marriage. The narrative constantly shifts viewpoints to test rival theories. It hits that sweet spot of lingering uncertainty, leaving you interrogating physical evidence and hidden motives right until the finale.
IMDb: 7.1 | Where to watch: Prime Video
3. Love & Death (2023)
Elizabeth Olsen brings manic suburban desperation to the story of Candy Montgomery. What starts as a quiet, church-sanctioned affair with a friend’s husband violently spirals into a blood-soaked utility room showdown. Olsen captures the unsettling, bubbly facade of an ordinary woman pushed to the brink. If you crave domestic secrets bubbling under pleasant smiles, this electric drama belongs on your watchlist.
IMDb: 7.5 | Where to watch: Netflix
4. Candy (2022)
Jessica Biel takes the reins for this sweatier, deeply claustrophobic alternate look at the Montgomery tragedy. Set against humid 1980s Texas, the narrative slow-burns through stifling community expectations, marital boredom, and frantic self-defense claims. For viewers chasing shows like Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story, this version zeros in on neighborhood gossip, female rivalries, and the shocking violence hiding behind picket fences.
IMDb: 7.1 | Where to watch: Hulu
5. Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story (2024)
Ryan Murphy trades Victorian parlors for Beverly Hills mansions in this lavish family tragedy. Accused of gunning down their parents in 1989, Lyle and Erik face a brutal media circus and cutthroat trials. Between explosive abuse allegations and contradictory testimony, you never know who to trust. It delivers the same sensational courtroom warfare that kept you glued to the Borden household.
Also Read: 17 Best True Crime Documentaries
IMDb: 7.7 | Where to watch: Netflix
6. The Act (2019)
Patricia Arquette and Joey King deliver powerhouse performances in this terrifying look at Munchhausen syndrome by proxy. Trapped beneath Dee Dee’s suffocating medical lies, Gypsy Rose plots a desperate, fatal escape with her secret boyfriend. It trades axe swings for toxic codependency, offering a deeply unsettling examination of domestic control that pushes a young woman straight toward matricide.
IMDb: 7.8 | Where to watch: Hulu
7. Under the Banner of Heaven (2022)
Andrew Garfield is mesmerizing as an earnest detective whose Mormon faith shatters while investigating the brutal murder of Brenda Lafferty and her infant. As religious fanaticism and toxic patriarchy collide across a sprawling clan, the tension becomes unbearable. It is one of the most layered shows like Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story, expertly weaving together period atmosphere, violent dogma, and harrowing family secrets.
IMDb: 7.5 | Where to watch: Hulu
8. American Crime Story (2016-2021)
Whether digging into O.J. Simpson or Linda Tripp, this anthology is the gold standard for high-stakes legal combat. Each season dissects how sensational trials become national obsessions, weaponized by media narratives and public bias. Anyone craving shows like Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story will appreciate the grand scale, legendary acting ensembles, and razor-sharp analysis of how justice gets compromised.
IMDb: 8.4 | Where to watch: Hulu
9. A Friend of the Family (2022)
This series unearths the deeply disturbing, true abduction saga of young Jan Broberg by charismatic family friend Robert Berchtold. It avoids cheap thrills to explore how predators manipulate religious trust and parental blind spots. For audiences drawn to shows like Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story, the harrowing look at psychological captivity inside an outwardly idyllic household hits remarkably close to home.
IMDb: 7.3 | Where to watch: Prime Video
10. Monster: The Ed Gein Story (2025)
Step away from high-society intrigue and plunge straight into rural isolation. Set across bleak 1950s Wisconsin, the series unpacks Gein’s suffocating maternal bond and the unspeakable relics unearthed on his farm. It swaps legal debates for pure psychological dread, yet fans hunting for shows like Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story will love the period aesthetic and chilling glimpse into an unraveling mind.
Also Read: 15 Shows Like Monster: The Ed Gein Story
IMDb: 6.9 | Where to watch: Netflix
11. Mindhunter (2017-2019)
David Fincher’s cerebral masterpiece trades courtroom theatrics for chilly basement interrogations. Two FBI agents and a psychologist pioneer behavioral analysis by interviewing incarcerated serial predators, slowly feeling the darkness bleed into their personal lives. It captures the exhausting grind of forensic discovery, making it essential viewing for fans fascinated by the murky psychology behind history’s most baffling crimes.
IMDb: 8.6 | Where to watch: Netflix
12. Black Bird (2022)
Taron Egerton stars as a convicted drug dealer tasked with entering a terrifying psychiatric prison to coax confessions out of suspected killer Larry Hall. Paul Walter Hauser’s whispery, chilling performance creates an unbearable level of cat-and-mouse tension. It is a tight, brilliant battle of wits that explores how darkness hides behind a meek, seemingly harmless facade.
IMDb: 8.1 | Where to watch: Apple TV
13. Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story (2022)
Rather than glorifying a killer, this grim chronicle examines the institutional neglect, ignored warnings, and systemic racism that let Dahmer operate undetected for over a decade. Evan Peters is genuinely terrifying, but the real weight belongs to the victims and neighbors. It provides a blistering indictment of botched investigations and community blind spots that true-crime junkies will find unforgettable.
IMDb: 7.7 | Where to watch: Netflix
14. Unbelievable (2019)
Kaitlyn Dever breaks your heart as a sexual assault survivor labeled a liar by negligent detectives, while Merritt Wever and Toni Collette step in years later to track a serial predator. It offers an unflinching, compassionate counterweight to sensationalist crime. If you appreciate gritty procedural integrity and furious takedowns of systemic police bias, this masterpiece demands your immediate attention.
IMDb: 8.3 | Where to watch: Prime Video
15. The Serpent (2021)
Tahar Rahim exudes venomous charisma as Charles Sobhraj, a con artist drugging and murdering backpackers across 1970s Asia. While globe-trotting escapes feel far removed from Fall River, the suspense matches up brilliantly. Watching an overlooked junior diplomat obsessively hunt down a sociopath scratches that exact investigative itch, proving true crime is just as gripping when bathed in vintage Bangkok sun.
IMDb: 7.6 | Where to watch: Netflix
Also Read: Latest OTT Releases This WeekÂ
There you have it. Whether you are in the mood for period corsets and ambiguous murderesses, nail-biting courtroom showdowns, or suffocating suburban secrets, these series will keep your remote hostage all weekend. Grab your snacks, pick your suspect, and let the binging begin.